arXiv:0909.4251v4
Abstract
Given and , we consider the set of such that is not a limit point of the sequence . Such sets are known to have full Hausdorff dimension, and in many cases have been shown to have a stronger property of being winning in the sense of Schmidt. In this paper, by utilizing Schmidt games, we prove that these sets and their bi-Lipschitz images must intersect with `sufficiently regular' fractals (that is, supporting measures satisfying certain decay conditions). Furthermore, the intersection has full dimension in if satisfies a power law (this holds for example if is the middle third Cantor set). Thus it follows that the set of numbers in the middle third Cantor set which are normal to no base has dimension .
AI-generated audit
Audit summary
Not a correctness certificate. A “Correct” result may include yellow typos or minor formal corrections that do not affect substantive soundness. It means this audit found no unresolved substantive error under the stated criteria; it does not replace expert scrutiny or formal verification.
Current report
Detailed mathematical audit
01Statements2 reported findingsCorrect
The winning theorem for lacunary affine images on supports of absolutely decaying measures, its countable-intersection consequences, and the normal-to-no-base corollary are correct.
Lacunary orbit-avoidance sets are winning on the fractal support
Page 3 and Section 4 (pages 9--12) · main theorem and proof · arXiv:0909.4251v4
Lacunarity bounds the number of scales at which lies in any fixed multiplicative window. Absolute decay lets Alice choose a subball avoiding a fixed positive proportion of the finitely many forbidden preimages at that scale. Iterating this choice keeps the limiting point a uniform distance from every prescribed target after applying , and the bi-Lipschitz distortion is absorbed in the fixed winning parameter.
Countable intersections and digit conclusions have the stated dimension
Page 4 and Section 5 (pages 13--15) · dimension and normality consequences · arXiv:0909.4251v4
Winning sets on the same support are stable under countable intersections. The power-law assumption identifies the support dimension with the decay exponent, so winning intersections have full relative Hausdorff dimension. For each integer base, avoiding a neighborhood of a periodic target bounds runs of a chosen digit; intersecting over bases and with badly approximable numbers gives the claimed normal-to-no-base set.
02Proofs2 reported findingsCorrect
The escaping lemma, scale scheduling, absolute-decay estimate, and Schmidt-game dimension argument are correct and complete.
Absolute decay supplies a legal escaping move
Pages 7--9 · finite-point escaping lemma · arXiv:0909.4251v4
The decay inequality bounds the measure occupied by each forbidden relative ball. The numerical choice of the game parameter makes the union of the relevant forbidden balls occupy less than the available parent ball, leaving a legal child ball centered on the support. The argument is uniform in the locations of the forbidden points.
Lacunarity schedules all constraints without collision
Pages 9--12 · proof of Theorem 1.1 and uniformly discrete extension · arXiv:0909.4251v4
At a given game scale only a bounded number of indices can have inverse-image spacing comparable with the current radius. The escaping lemma handles that entire finite collection before the radius enters the next scale. Earlier avoidances persist under nesting, and every index is eventually processed, yielding one positive avoidance constant for the limiting point.
03Novelty0 reported findingsNo non-novelty findings
No non-novelty findings.